buy windows xp 2010 cheap windows 7 keys on ebay web page maker 3 download purchase adobe acrobat 9 professional windows 7 price details purchase windows xp software buy windows xp canada sony vegas cheap 3ds max 2009 download buy windows 7 canada cheap acrobat 9 buy microsoft office accounting 2009 pctools spyware doctor 5.5 buy windows 2003 enterprise licensing windows 7 price compare where can i buy windows 7 enterprise buy windows 7 college discount buy windows 7 upgrade student discount purchase office 2007 product key buy adobe creative suite 3 for mac adobe illustrator cs3 download cheap adobe cs4 web premium omnipage pro 17 download buy office 2007 key buy windows 7 on ebay download 3d home architect design deluxe 8 purchase microsoft works 9 buy outlook 2007 download buy windows 7 teacher adobe captivate oem microsoft excel 2007 buy buy windows xp original buy solidworks software buy adobe creative suite cs4 adobe illustrator cs3 direct download buy windows 2008 server solidworks 2009 price purchase microsoft expression web 2 buy paperport 12 quicken rental property manager 2009 download purchase mathcad microsoft expression studio 3 download buy windows 7 full install download smith micro poser 7 best price corel draw buy windows 7 on sale buy sql server cheap corel draw 11 mac buy matlab r2009b pixologic zbrush 3 mac buy discount windows 7 pro purchase photoshop elements cheap photoshop elements download buy windows 7 family pack online microsoft visio 2007 pro discount windows 7 home premium oem buy windows 7 spanish guitar pro price microsoft office 2003 buy product key buy windows 7 touch screen monitor buy adobe font folio 11 download powerdirector 8 ultra download microsoft expression web 3 how much does windows 7 professional cost best price cakewalk sonar 7 buy windows xp cd key adobe captivate demo buy adobe photoshop elements 8 discount windows 7 oem microsoft office enterprise 2007 download buy microsoft office canada cheap dvd ripper platinum 5 pdf converter professional 6 download cheap microsoft office download buy windows 7 language pack windows 7 discount for vista owners buy windows 7 ultimate full purchase adobe acrobat pro buy office 2007 enterprise edition wavelab price windows 2003 enterprise license cost buy cheap adobe illustrator windows 7 best buy download avanquest powerdesk pro 7 cubase 4 download full buy microsoft office 10 avanquest mylogomaker professional 2 buy cheap photoshop cs4 extended cheap windows 7 software buy microsoft office 2003 online powerdvd 9 price buy dragon naturally speaking 10 purchase windows 7 ultimate 64 bit purchase microsoft office online buy autodesk 3ds max cheap nuance paperport 12 download vmware workstation 6.5 discount buy windows xp uk best buy microsoft windows xp buy adobe illustrator cs3 adobe photoshop mac price buy windows vista get windows 7 free download corel draw software cheap autocad 2009 discount microsoft streets & trips 2010 download encarta 2009 buy office 2007 professional plus purchase windows xp embedded autodesk mudbox 2009 download cheap windows xp download ms visio 2007 price windows 7 price in uk download acdsee photo editor 2008 acrobat download 9 windows 7 professional price uk buy microsoft office 2003 license pixologic zbrush 3 mac download buy windows xp pc world i.r.i.s. readiris pro 11 buy photoshop elements 8.0 buy windows xp retail download mcafee antivirus 2009 buy windows 7 student uk buy presenter buy quickbooks premier 2010 autosketch 10 download microsoft to offer cheap windows 7 for students buy windows 7 cheap for students vmware workstation 7 price buy windows 7 32 bit adobe premiere download download propellerhead reason 4 mac microsoft word 2007 online download adobe cs4 design premium for mac buy windows xp service pack 3 buy windows 7 deals buy adobe fireworks cs4 buy word 2007 download buy microsoft office upgrade windows xp cheap download abbyy finereader 9.0 price buy windows 7 in new zealand buy windows 7 israel norton ghost 12 price adobe flash cs3 for mac purchase microsoft office home and student 2007 adobe indesign cs3 cheap buy microsoft excel 2003 microsoft office 2007 price in malaysia buy office 2007 small business edition buy windows xp sp2 cd windows 7 price korea buy symantec ghost buy microsoft encarta 2009 buy roxio copy & convert 3 buy windows 7 ebay where can i buy windows 7 basic where can i buy sony vegas pro 9 cheap cakewalk sonar 7 buy windows 7 philippines symantec winfax pro 10.4 buy windows xp for business buy sony vegas cheap download windows 2008 r2 buy adobe contribute mac buy adobe cs4 academic buy wordperfect x3 purchase microsoft expression studio 3 buy indesign cs2 adobe photoshop price compare buy windows 7 mac microsoft office 2003 buy online lightroom for mac download download 3ds max 2010 buy propellerhead reason 4 buy windows 7 for students download indesign cs4 buy windows 7 canada online download guitar pro for mac buy windows 7 home premium retail buy microsoft office uk download autosketch 9 purchase windows xp pro key download adobe flash cs4 professional mac cheap microsoft office xp buy windows xp sp3 oem buy adobe cs3 master collection corel photoimpact 12 quarkxpress 8 activation download lightroom 2.5 microsoft windows 7 discount code cheap adobe after effects cs4 buy outlook 2007 buy windows 7 keys purchase quickbooks 2009 premier buy creative suite 4 download adobe after effects cs3 deskshare videoeditmagic 4.3 price download matlab r2008a microsoft office 2003 product key windows 7 discount uk quickbooks enterprise 9.0 download cheap zonealarm internet security suite 8 windows vista price drop download solidworks 2009 purchase windows xp installation disc how to buy windows 7 starter edition purchase office 2007 student edition buy microsoft office 97 office 2007 price australia buy quickbooks premier 2009 robohelp pricing cheap windows xp license get autodesk 3ds max 2010 windows 7 price chart corel video studio download buy cheap dreamweaver cs4 cheap microsoft powerpoint purchase office 2007 online buy windows 7 thailand navisworks download microsoft expression price buy adobe flash cs4 buy windows vista home premium product key autocad electrical 2010 price microsoft office 2007 price list buy windows xp singapore purchase windows 7 amazon purchase corel draw 11 mac adobe software for mac acronis true image cheap windows vista buy uk buy office 2003 small business buy microsoft office basic 2007 purchase adobe acrobat for mac final cut express 4 price buy windows xp nz autodesk autocad price buy adobe photoshop lightroom 2 mac buy adobe audition 1.5 purchase adobe indesign cs4 windows 7 price yahoo avid media composer buy buy microsoft money 2005 photoshop cs4 prices buy windows 7 oem license windows 7 ultimate buy online download inventor lt 2010 cheap adobe after effects for mac windows 7 ultimate price cheap photoshop cs3 navisworks manage 2009 buy windows xp student edition microsoft office discount coupon buy microsoft office pro microsoft money home and business 2009 buy microsoft access only buy windows xp for mac download nero 8 ultra edition cheap adobe photoshop cs3 buy windows xp at walmart buy microsoft vista product key buy photoshop cs download microsoft works 9 autocad electrical 2009 download buy microsoft office access sony acid pro 7 price microsoft office price history download dreamweaver cs3 full version buy microsoft office license buy guitar pro 5 dreamweaver mac oem microsoft office discount canada pinnacle studio price buy windows vista starter download after effects cs4 portable cheapest windows 7 deal windows 7 discount deals buy photoshop serial number buy windows 7 key only cheap microsoft powerpoint 2003 buy vista oem dvd moviefactory 6 plus buy flash cs3 buy photoshop illustrator buy windows xp licence key cheap i.r.i.s. readiris pro 11 buy photoshop cs5 where to purchase windows 7 starter buy vista ultimate download microsoft office 2003 professional windows 7 price for students purchase windows 7 half price cheap adobe photoshop software buy windows 7 south africa nuendo 4 download native instruments traktor dj studio 3.4 price purchase adobe photoshop elements 6 buy windows 7 for 30 purchase office 2007 standard visual studio 2008 download purchase vista business buy adobe acrobat pro 9 autocad 2010 system requirements autocad electrical 2010 download norton 360 cost buy microsoft project 2007 buy windows 7 professional 64 bit oem adobe robohelp price adobe after effects demo download acdsee pro 2 buy windows 7 as a student download microsoft frontpage 2003 adobe creative suite 3 web premium download microsoft office 2003 oem download cheap adobe creative suite software cheap illustrator cs4 windows 7 price at best buy buy photoshop elements 6 cheap adobe indesign mac cheap microsoft visio 2007 windows 7 professional oem vs retail price windows 7 ultimate windows 7 professional 32-bit oem download microsoft digital image suite 10 dvd ripper platinum 5 price best price microsoft streets and trips 2009 adobe suite cs3 price parallels 5 price microsoft word 2003 online download cheap windows xp professional buy windows xp 64 bit buy acid pro 7 quicken 2010 discount buy windows 7 pakistan solidworks prices sound forge audio studio 9 price windows 7 ultimate license adobe premiere pro cs3 mac buy autocad 2010 cheap acronis disk director discount buy turbotax 2006 windows 2008 standard pricing windows xp price in pakistan ms streets and trips 2010 download pinnacle studio 14 price buy windows 7 oem ultimate trial powerdvd 7 download adobe cs4 production premium for mac buy microsoft office mac corel painter 10 for mac

Southern Weekend interview with Sichuan education official Lin Qiang

This interview is with an outspoken education official from Sichuan named Lin Qiang and was featured in a recent issue of Southern Weekend, a newspaper based out of Guangzhou, known (in the past), for some more independent, hard-hitting news and coverage of events.

Lin Qiang had been chosen to be a torch-bearer and was also invited to watch the opening ceremonies of the Olympic Games, but has forgone these privileges out of a deep sense of shame and remorse for what he believes was the unnecessarily large of loss of life from the earthquake. He has some somewhat harsh words to say about the system and the behavior of officials in the aftermath of the earthquake.

Here’s my rough translation for what it’s worth.

Southern Weekend (SW): To be a torch bearer and also be able to watch the Olympics is a great honor, but you have chosen
forgo this honor, which is quite surprising. What considerations went into your decision?

Lin Qiang (Lin Qiang): It’s mostly because of my mood. Right now, my heart feels very heavy.

SW: Why is that?

LQ: So many schools collapsed and so many innocent children were lost as a result of the earthquake, and I think that anyone with a modicum of conscience would find this hard to accept, and more so for one who is a education official.

SW: So what you meanb is that as an educatoinal official, you believe that you hold a certain responsibility fo rwhat happened?

LQ: Of course, The shcools collapsing is a societal event, so the entire society bears responsibility. Howeever, the educational system bears a greater responsibility. As an educational official, I ought to feel a great sense of guilt.

SW: When did you start feeeling this sense of guilt?

LQ: From the very moment that I began witnessing these tragic events.

SW: Can be a bit more specific about the circumstances?

LQ: I was perhaps one of the first Sichuan education officials to arrive at the epicenter. I received orders on the morning of the 13th and sent a group of disaster relief experts to Beichuan. By the time that we got to the disaster relief control center inside a Beichuan middle school, it was already 5 am on the morning of the 14th. The relief team immediately launched into action, and I couldn’t really do much else, so I took a video recorder and walked around the county town. At that point the roads from the relief center to the county town were not yet cleared, and no motor vehicles could get through, so most of the disaster relief teams were confined to the Beichuan middle school. I wanted to see for myself what was happening in the county town.

SW: What was the most shocking thing that you’ve seen?

LQ: I saw a parent crying. A five story building collapsed, pinning his child down. There were no rescue teams around, and the parent watched the life slipping away from his child, and could do nothing about it. Four hours before I arrived, the child had died right before their parent’s eyes. The parent kept crying and murmuring “that’s my baby, my baby had such good grades in school.”

SW: Were you at all mentally prepared for this kind of situation?

LQ: There is no way you could be prepared for this kind of thing. I felt horrible.

SW: What was your first reaction?

LQ: The first thing I did was to take all the money that I had on me–I was in a hurry and didn’t have that much on me at the time, maybe just a couple thousand yuan–and I took it out and gave it all to him, and he said, no, my child is dead, what would I need money for. The people around us took the money and put it in his pocket. I knew that the money had no meaning for him, but this was the only “relief” that I could offer, at the time, there was nothing else I could do.

SW: In fact, this was just a instinctive attempt at self-redemption.

LQ: Right. It was an attempt at redeeming myself. At the time I felt especially guilty. As a educational official, I didn’t bear directly responsibility for what happened, but still, my conscience made me feel as I’d somehow wronged the child and the parents.

SW: You actually don’t have to be that self-critical, it was a level 8 earthquake, there was nothing much that you could do about that. For example, the Ministry of Education of Sichuan province just released their five main reasons why the buildings collapsed. One was that the earthquake was just much more powerful than they had expected. Secondly, the earthquake unfortunately happened while the kids were at school. Thirdly, the schools have crowded classrooms and corridors. Fourthly, the schools and dormitories are rather old and backwards. Fifthly, the schools were properly earthquake-proofed and therefore flawed from the beginning.

LQ: Yes, of course it was a natural disaster, but natural disasters don’t always lead to human tragedies, and to blame the tragedies on nature is just morally lazy.

SW: So, when you arrived at the scene, were you witnessing a tragedy or a natural disaster?

LQ: For the most part, I think it was a tragedy. It wasn’t as if those students were meant to die, and it’s not as if that school that they were at was meant to collapse. I took a picture of another school, which was just about 7-800 meters away from Beichuan middle school, which didn’t collapse, and in which no one died and only three people were injured.

SW: Why was there such a difference?

LQ: The reason is quite simple. The schools that did not collapse were Project Hope schools created by the Central Academy of Sciences. There was oversight from the donors, thus ensuring the quality of construction. The schools that collapsed were mostly not, when built, subject to that kind of oversight and control. There was no way to guarantee the quality of their construction.

SW: That is to say, it wasn’t purely the natural disaster that killed these people. It was a lack of oversight and a systemic inertia that ended up enlarging the deadly effects of natural disaster.

LQ: Natural and man-made disasters have always “worked hand in hand”. I wasn’t so aware of this point before, when I had thought that the worst that could happen was economic damage and not a huge loss of human life. But having witnessed this tragedy first-hand, to say that it was “extremely brutal” (translators note: hard to translate Chinese idiom here) is not at all inappropriate. This was a real blow to me and really shook me to my soul. From that moment on, I just couldn’t stomach any more denying of responsibility (or pushing it onto others). If, in front of the departed souls of the children and these broken homes, we still adhere to the ‘rules of the game’ where officials protect each other so that we’re all ok–that would just be unconscionable and utterly shameless. At the point we would have lost our humanity, to say nothing of being an educator.

SW: So you decided to forgo your right to be a torch-bearer and watch the Olympics?

LQ: Yes. On a certain level, I’m guilty for what happened and therefore ought to serve penance for it. I ought to kneel in front of the dead children, their families, and this society, instead of being given honorific robes. But I have no other way of redeeming myself, so have decided to forgo my role as torch-bearer instead.

SW: Will your request be approved?

LQ: I still don’t know. But I hope that this small request will be respected. And I know that I am not just forgoing my role, I am also hoping that Mr. Zhang Yimou will be able to understand and feel the mood around the country and the severe blow it has dealt all of us and make the appropriate adjustment to his preparation for the opening ceremonies.

SW: In what regard do you think he should make adjustments?

LQ: I think that it still ought to big, but less flamboyant, more solemn and down to earth, and should somehow express the people’s feelings of compassion and sympathy towards all living beings. I would think under present circumstances, it would be hard to imagine an opening ceremony that didn’t somehow express this. Of course, it’s not just a matter of the opening ceremonies, the entire mood of the Olympics ought to be adjusted. Our pain and our sorrow–but also our strength and perseverance–ought to be the main thrust of the Olympics.

SW: That sounds like a good idea, but how do we implement it?

LQ: Let’s begin with the selection of the torch-bearers. Let’s try to give as many of the chances to be torch-bearers and watch the opening ceremonies to the heroes of the earthquake relief efforts or the families of the victims and the NPC officials from the hard-hit areas, thus expressing the Chinese peoples’ spirit of perseverance and making the passing of the torch into a symbolic transmission of life and spirit.

SW: Your thinking on this has real value. But is this way of thinking representative of the educational system?

LQ: To be honest, it probably doesn’t, it’s more just my personal views.

SW: I’ve heard some people say, in the past people used to always criticize China for this and that, but now they can all shut up, because after this earthquake, the Chinese educational system has had some exceptional achievements, teachers have helped rescue people, and even sacrificed their own lives trying to protect their students; many students were brave as well and tried to rescue their classmates. This heroic actions and deeds prove that the Chinese educational system is in fact successful.

LQ: These opinions are quite common in the administrative system, but that fact points a very big problem with the system. If you look at it from another, more human perspective, you would reach the opposite conclusion. Sure, those teachers are heroes, and those children are heroes, but heroism doesn’t always require that sacrifice your life.

If we, administrators and officials in the educational system, had done our jobs and not let corruption gain a foothold, then maybe more dorms and schools would be as sturdy as the Project Hope school in Beichuan, and those teachers and children wouldn’t have had to die, and we could avoided all these tragedies. The people that most deserved and needed protection didn’t get it, and instead died unnaturally–this should be a great source of shame for all of us who work in the educational system. We ought to reflect, we ought to feel a deep sense of remorse, and not use these heroes or the tragedy itself to slough off our own responsibilities and make ourselves look good.

SW: I notice that you tend to emphasize the words “bei min” (pity, sympathy, compassion)

LQ: The reason why I do that is because that’s what the educational system lacks the most.

SW: What specific instances of this are there?

LQ: As of now, we still have not yet actively attempted a systemic analysis of why our buildings collapsed or any serious inquest (including the collecting of evidence) into responsibilities of what happened. Furthermore, we haven’t even offered a formal apology to the families of the deceased–all of these feelings of responsibility and measures designed to protect human life must not concern us too much–these are specific instances.

The parents who lost their children in the earthquake have tears in their eyes and yet are constantly searching through the rubble to construction materials that can serve as evidence for future investigations. As an educator, and as a civil servant, we ought to feel a great sense of shame and remorse and yet be grateful for their actions. We ought to respect them, and we ought to support them. However, not many people in the educational system are willing to think like that, and even less people are willing to do that. Of course, everyone is very busy, trying to arrange the university examinations for people in the affected areas, finding and rewarding model workers among those involved in disaster relief, gathering statistics and date on the damage, and planning the eventual reconstruction. But no matter what, you cannot deny that the departed souls of the children, their parents, and this entire society–demand an explanation. If a tragedy of this scale cannot occasion any reflection or explanation on our part, and if we always put our own reputations and futures ahead of the lives of children, then how can we ever really lift our spirits or improve the system? How can we ever guarantee that tragedy will never strike again?

Leave a Reply

generic viagra levitra and cialis pills Buy Viagra Online can i take viagra
Close
E-mail It