This CNN article has the number of dead pegged at 4 but it seems that now the official number of dead has risen to five. What makes the whole thing much much worse is the fact that, according to one SIna report that we read, that problems were discovered a month ago. Check out what is said in this paragraph:
金德水责问地铁施工相关负责人:“是否在事故之前就曾发现过事故隐患?”该负责人表示确实存在隐患。赵铁锤随即痛批,为什么不事先采取措施解除隐患?相关负责人表示,已经和上级部门汇报过,需要等待上级批示。
三位领导均表示,不可能有这种事,出现这么重大的安全隐患,施工单位应该及时采取措施补救,根本不需要等待审批。
The leaders–provincial and city officials–asked some of the construction company reps if there really had been problems discovered earlier–and the reps said yes, and then the officials asked why immediate measures were not taken to solve the problem, and the reps said that they needed to report the problem to their superiors and wait for approval. And the officials said that a problem of this seriousness did not have to go through that whole bureaucratic rigamarole.
If you’ve lived in China, and know Chinese people—this kind of tragedy is nothing new. The numbness follows and subdues the anger much more quickly now, because you almost expect this kind of thing to happen on a regular basis in China. They are notoriously bad on worker safety. They are known around the world for cutting corners at the cost of human life.
I’ve had enough of people dying needlessly of late, what with Tom passing away and then this shit. Every fucking day. Every fucking day. This shit and this shit world. How do you manage to go on, without your consciousness bludgeoned by fear? You know full well that people around are NOT trying their best to keep you alive and healthy. They aren’t wishing for your death, but this kind of laxity really just drives you insane because it implies that for someone, somewhere, decisions are being made that place something else above human life in value. And guess what, there are very few things in life that have greater value than a human being’s life, and the meaning in each person’s existence.
3 responses so far ↓
1 April Fong // Nov 17, 2008 at 2:10 pm
The Beichuan schools, and now this.
2 YB // Nov 17, 2008 at 2:34 pm
I agree. But that’s just not the prevailing view in China, a formerly (officially still) communist State, collectivist society, with centuries, if not MILLENIA of history pointing to “greater good” always being more valuable to any individual number of human lives (construction of the Great Wall comes to mind ?).
It’s terrible… but is it new ? and can it be changed? And do they want it to be changed… Maybe you, and me, as foreigners… shouldn’t be bearing the moral burden of the way the chinese society works… ? Not saying we shouldn’t care anymore… but, if the very people at the heart of the matter, themselves, don’t care… just how much power do we have left ?
3 SNR // Nov 18, 2008 at 1:53 am
Your idea of a greater good makes no sense. What greater good would mean people don’t care about others dying? I don’t see how producing shoddy construction has anything to do with the greater good. It’s simply greed and corruption. Also the great wall was built from slave and forced labour, no one volunteered to make the wall for the greater good.
Leave a Comment